Blog
A smiling front desk staff member in blue scrubs reviews paperwork on a clipboard with a parent at a therapy clinic check-in counter, representing families navigating insurance plan acceptance with therapy providers.

Why Don’t All Therapy Providers Accept Every Insurance Plan?

Insurance, Parent Education

QUICK ANSWER

Therapy providers don’t accept every insurance plan for a few consistent, practical reasons: joining a specific insurance network requires a lengthy credentialing process, reimbursement rates vary significantly by payer and are sometimes too low to sustain quality care, and administrative burden, like prior authorization requirements, can make certain plans genuinely difficult to work with. This isn’t about any particular family or plan. It reflects real structural realities in how insurance networks and provider reimbursement actually work. 

Joining a Network Is Its Own Lengthy Process

Becoming an in-network provider with a specific insurance company requires a formal credentialing process, verifying licenses, education, and practice history, that can take months to complete for each individual payer. A practice has to weigh whether the administrative investment of credentialing with a given insurer is worth it relative to how many local families that plan would actually serve. Even once a provider is credentialed, network status can vary within a single carrier. Insurance companies often offer dozens of different plans, each with its own network agreement, so a provider might be in-network with Blue Cross Blue Shield’s PPO plan, for example, but not with one of its HMO or exchange plans. This is part of why it’s worth confirming your specific plan’s network status directly rather than assuming coverage based on the carrier’s name alone. 

Reimbursement Rates Vary Significantly by Payer

Insurance companies negotiate different reimbursement rates with each provider, and some payers reimburse well below what it actually costs a practice to deliver quality, individualized pediatric care. When rates are set unsustainably low for a given plan, accepting that insurance can genuinely threaten a practice’s ability to maintain adequate staffing, manageable caseloads, and consistent care quality. This is a real financial calculation providers have to make, not an arbitrary decision about which families they’d prefer to work with.

Taken together, these are the main factors behind a provider’s decision to accept, or not accept, a specific insurance plan:

  • Credentialing with a specific payer is a lengthy, resource-intensive process
  • Reimbursement rates vary significantly and are sometimes too low to sustain quality care
  • Administrative requirements like prior authorization add ongoing burden per payer
  • A provider may accept many plans while still not accepting every single one

Administrative Burden Compounds Over Time

Beyond the initial credentialing process, staying in-network with a specific payer involves ongoing administrative work: prior authorization requests, reauthorization cycles, appeals when claims are denied, and compliance with each payer’s specific documentation requirements. Research has found that prior authorization delays negatively affect patient outcomes and have caused a significant share of clinicians to drop at least one payer network entirely, since the administrative burden of maintaining that relationship outweighs its practical value1. This is exactly the kind of structural pressure that leads some practices to step back from specific plans over time, even ones they previously accepted.

PULL QUOTE 

“It’s never personal. It’s usually math, credentialing capacity, reimbursement rates, administrative load, that a practice has to weigh honestly if it wants to keep delivering quality care.”

— Stefanie Blaser, Vice President, RCM, Westside Children’s Therapy

What This Means for Your Family

If a provider you’re considering doesn’t accept your specific plan, that decision almost always reflects one of these structural factors, credentialing capacity, reimbursement sustainability, or administrative burden, rather than anything about your family specifically2. It’s worth asking a provider directly which plans they do accept and why they’ve made the choices they have about network participation, since a straightforward answer tells you something useful about how transparently that provider operates more broadly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a provider not accepting my insurance mean something is wrong with my plan?

No. It usually reflects the provider’s own credentialing capacity, reimbursement rates, or administrative burden with that specific payer, not a judgment about your plan.

How long does it take a provider to join a new insurance network?

The credentialing process can take months, which is part of why providers are selective about which specific payers they pursue.

Why would a provider stop accepting a plan they used to be in-network with?

This sometimes happens when reimbursement rates or administrative burden for that specific payer become unsustainable relative to the practice’s ability to maintain quality care.

Should I ask a provider directly why they don’t accept my plan?

Yes. A provider willing to explain their reasoning clearly is generally being transparent, and their answer can help you understand your broader options.

Are these issues specific to pediatric therapy, or common across healthcare generally?

These structural insurance issues, credentialing, reimbursement rates, prior authorization burden, are common across many healthcare fields, not unique to pediatric therapy.

What This Actually Comes Down To

When a provider doesn’t accept a specific insurance plan, it almost always comes down to credentialing, reimbursement, or administrative burden, not anything about your family or your plan specifically.

If you’re trying to figure out your options, see Finding Insurance Plans for ABA Therapy for more guidance. If you have questions about which insurance plans we accept, we’re glad to help. Call us at 815-783-2544 or submit a contact form.

Know a family confused about why a provider doesn’t take their insurance? Share this with them. It might be exactly what they needed today.

Authored by Stefanie Blaser, Vice President, RCM, Westside Children’s Therapy

Where to Go Next

 

  1. Pediatric & Speech/OT Therapy Statistics (2026). The Relay Co.
  2. Why So Many Therapists Don’t Take Insurance: What the Numbers Show. TopDoctor Magazine.